Environmental impact assessment reclamation of 15 hectares of land at Thilafushi for development of the regional waste management facility for Zone 3

Abstract

This report discusses the findings of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) study undertaken by Water Solutions Pvt. Ltd. at the request of Ministry of Environment and Energy for the proposed reclamation of 15 hectares from the shallow lagoon at Thilafalhu, Male’ Atoll. Thilafalhu is the lagoon where Thilafushi is located. The reclamation and coastal protection project is the first step to establish a Regional Waste Management Facility for Zone III at Thilafushi to manage and dispose waste which is generated from islands in the central 4 atolls of the Maldives. The reclamation project involves reclamation 15 hectares of shallow lagoon at Thilafalhu, Thilafushi to height of +1.7 m above mean sea level. Sand is proposed to be borrowed from the lagoon of Thilafushi near the reclamation area located on northern side of the proposed site. It is estimated that total of 525,000 cbm of sand will be required for this reclamation. The sand would be dredged using Cutter Suction Dredger and dredged sand will be pumped to the reclamation area from the dredger. The reclaimed land would be protected using 510 m rock boulder revetment on southern side and 475 m revetment on northern side. Ministry of Environment and Energy would undertake a detail design using their engineer based on observations, issues, and concerns raised during the EIA process. Environmental impacts of this project were assessed and most of the environmental impacts of the project have been identified as resulting from the dredging and reclamation works. Dredging to borrow sand for the reclamation work will be undertaken using Cutter Suction Dredger and this is particularly a method that creates lot of sedimentation. Reclamation work for filling and levelling work would be undertaken using excavators and bulldozer which will have an impact on the marine environment during the initial stage of the project. It is anticipated that impacts of this projects will be felt on the marine environment of the Thialfushi reef system. Mitigation measures for the negative impacts have been identified and outlined in the report. Sedimentation control methods have been specifically focused to reduce its impact on the surrounding marine environment. An important mitigation measure is the use of bund walls in the reclamation area to contain sedimentation and reduce its impact on the marine environment. In addition, completing the dredging and filling works in the shortest time frame, during north east monsoon is also a significant mitigation measure to minimize the impact of sedimentation on the marine environment. The proposed mitigation measures shall be followed in order to minimize environmental damage. The measures proposed to mitigate environmental impacts is considered to be appropriate, thereby minimizing the impact by about 90%. The negative environmental impacts of the proposed project would be sedimentation and destruction of the lagoon and damage to some areas of the reef, which will cause death of corals in the direct impact zone and partial death of corals in other areas of the coral reef. During dredging works, the sedimentation will also affect the fish species in the vicinity of the project area. Several alternatives to the proposed project were considered, all of these alternatives cannot be implemented for various reasons including issues related to regulations, cost, and environment factors. The present project design seems to be feasible option in terms of costs, durability and safety. It is inevitable that there would be negative environmental impacts of this project. It will not be possible to avoid environmental damage entirely, but ways to minimize damage are critical factors to consider during implementation. An Environmental Management Plan (EMP) with environmental monitoring has been recommended including important elements that require regular checks. This monitoring component shall be adhered to and will allow the assessment of changes due to the implementation of the proposed project. As the socioeconomic impacts are going to be felt in the long term, monitoring these changes is very essential. The proposed reclamation pose threats to the marine environment of the Thilafushi and its lagoon. There will be direct and indirect damage to marine environment in the vicinity of the project site. Some of the corals patches, mostly in the reclamation area in the shallow lagoon will die due to smothering as well as from construction activities. But these are damages that cannot be entirely avoided. The project involves negative environmental impacts, such impacts are not severe as not to go ahead with this project. The project is justifiable in light of the socio-economic conditions and anticipated benefits resulting from the project, which seem to outweigh the negative environmental impacts.